SOLDIERS OF IDF VS ARAB TERRORISTS

SOLDIERS OF IDF VS ARAB TERRORISTS

Monday, October 9, 2023

A ruthless response is absolutely legitimate I can only add my voice of responsibility to confer legitimacy to as ruthless a military response as Israel can muster

 My heart is in the East, and I am in the utmost corner of the West.

I feel inadequate as my heart beats elsewhere. My readers know my compromised health situation. I am an Orthodox Jew who believes deeply in the G-d of Israel, and I simply cannot find it in myself to argue with Him over my health situation that — meantime — confines me in America.

I cannot argue with Him over tragedies of far greater consequence than mine: the destruction of the Holy Temples, the Crusades and Blood Libel Massacres, the Black Death massacres and the Inquisition, the Pogroms and the Holocaust. They each were of far greater consequence than my own personal tragedies.

I cannot argue with Him for my righteous Dad z"l dying of leukemia at his age 45, my 14; or my beloved Ellen z"l dying of glioblastoma at her age 64, or my incapacitating interstitial lung disease that resulted in my reduced capacity and enhanced vulnerability after a life-saving lung transplant that — in the meantime — once again set back my Aliyah plans.

So I at least have the humility to acknowledge that I am now not on the front lines of the Jewish people’s latest war for survival. Part of me commands not to write but to remain quiet. I have no right.

But for Zion’s sake I cannot hold my peace, and for Jerusalem I cannot remain quiet. You in Israel have every right not to read a word of this if you believe my voice should be still. But I must speak nonetheless.

Here is what I can add to the struggle: A voice that a great many people deem honorable and respectable. I am national Vice President of Coalition for Jewish Values, an association that speaks for 2,500 Anglophonic traditional rabbis, primarily in the United States but also throughout the world. I served six years on the Executive Committee of the Rabbinical Council of America and have chaired and served on several RCA committees. For the past twenty years, I have been a member of the National Council of Young Israel rabbinic council, and major Young Israel national publications have carried my Torah writings. I have been a law professor for twenty years, was Chief Articles Editor of UCLA Law Review, and have been awarded major awards for legal ethics. I am a Senior Contributing Editor of The American Spectator.

I can go on. This list already is too much, but my point is that I am not a tummler but speak with authority, responsibility, and am recognized as an expert in legal ethics, winner of the American Jurisprudence Award in Legal Ethics.

Therefore I submit my voice, as the Holy Season of Judaism has come to a conclusion in Exile, to validate ethically as ruthless a military response as Israel can muster:

1. It is imperative, if Israel is capable of doing so, that it exterminate Hamas. Again: exterminate. Leave nothing behind of Hamas.

2. It is imperative, if Israel is capable of doing so, that it exterminate Islamic Jihad. Again: exterminate. Leave nothing behind of Islamic Jihad.

3. It is imperative, if Israel is capable of doing so, that it target all Hamas and Islamic Jihad leaders for extermination and exterminate them.

4. Any such leaders who are in hiding must be exterminated as soon as they are found, even twenty years from now.

5. Stop the hagzamah (exaggeration). This was not “Israel’s 9/11.” The Yom Kippur War was Israel’s 9/11. That was an attack on Yom Kippur. It resulted in 3,000 deaths. Other than for Israeli governmental incompetence, it was not the fault of the Israeli Knesset.

6. This happened because Ariel Sharon handed over Gaza to the Arabs, and the entire Labor Party and all the moral predecessors of Meretz and Labor and Yesh Atid voted for it, and others from Likud joined with Ariel Sharon in breaking from the Likud’s official platform. This is what the Left and the spineless “Moderates” did to Israel when they acceded to Sharon handing over Gaza to the Arabs. That day, decided on Tisha B’Av 2005 and then symbolically delayed a day, birthed this attack and war — and all the prior Hamas attacks and wars.

7. This would never have happened if Netanyahu and Israel had fought a previous Hamas War to victory instead of just “mowing the lawn.” And if America did not stop us as well.

8. Israel should not and must not go out of its way to kill even one single Arab civilian “innocent” as an act of revenge, but Israel must not hesitate to kill and exterminate every single terrorist and terror objective, even if it will mean the collateral loss of thousands of civilians. The terrorists base themselves in apartment buildings, schools, hospitals, mosques, ambulances, and other profoundly civilian non-combatant locations. Each such site must be deemed fair game for utter elimination, and no civilian’s presence can justify refraining from exterminating every terror site in Gaza.

Moreover, let it never be forgotten that Hamas came to power in Gaza by means of democratic elections. The population of Gaza have voted for them repeatedly. They are no more innocent than German voters in Dresden who elected Hitler.

9. This must not be a “mowing the lawn” operation but an utter extermination, not the intentional extermination of the civilian population of Gaza, but the utter extermination of Gaza terror, come what may.

10. Israel will win this war handily because it is not an attack on the country alone but an attack on the G-d of Israel, launching deliberately on Sh’mini Atzeret. This was Sadat’s great mistake: he launched his war not only against Israel the country but against the G-d of Israel by striking on Yom Kippur. That is why he never had a chance to win, despite the incompetent Israeli leadership then of Golda Meir and Moshe Dayan. Tellingly, Sadat struck on the secular calendar day of October 6, and G-d left His thumbprint on Sadat’s demise by snuffing him out on October 6 (1981).

11. Avigdor Liberman has offered to join an emergency national unity government if the Israeli government will commit to wipe out Hamas and its leadership. This offer should be warmly accepted. First, it will signal that this indeed will not merely be a “mowing” operation but a war of extinction. Secondly, it will add meaningful legitimacy to the coalition’s actions. Thirdly, it will strike a terrible morale blow to the Left and their 27 Million Shekel demonstrations to see the biggest Bibi Hater of them all sitting in coalition with him. Fourth, it will open a door for Liberman’s later finding a way back in to join an impregnable right-wing coalition, even alongside the religious parties he presently hates, once Netanyahu departs from the political coalition, perhaps three years hence or sooner.

Liberman cannot stand sitting in a coalition that depends for its majority on “The Religious.” But he also cannot stand sitting in a coalition that depends for its majority on “The Arabs.” He hates both. But he lives in Judea-Samaria, not in Rahat or Umm al-Fahm. Bring him in. Also, only by bringing him in can he later be kicked out.

12. Things happen for reasons. And those reasons are part of G-d’s mighty hand and outstretched arm. The minute that nine months of leftist civil disruption escalated to physically attacking public Yom Kippur prayers in the center of Israel’s most populous city, this war became inevitable as G-d’s horrible, terrible punishment that also will begin the process of healing tensions flaming toward civil war.

I have been a rav for more than forty years. Horrible tragedies bring torn families together. Those who read me regularly know I have been predicting something along these lines would be bringing all the boycotting pilots back to their planes and releasing the pent-up steam inflamed by the G-dless Shiksa Bresslers and Ehud Baraks. Barak wanted dead Jewish bodies and now he has them — but he will not hear his imagined wistful voices begging him to return to leadership. They will continue urging him to go back to Jeffrey Epstein Island where he belongs.

13. It is very, very hard that 100 or more Jewish hostages have been taken. I do not write in euphemisms but in truths: It will be impossible to recover Jewish hostages from Arab terrorists without paying prices that guarantee even more mass killings of many more innocent Jews than are freed by releasing hundreds of Arab murderers. This is why Hamas and Islamic Jihad — this time — must be utterly exterminated, and the bombings must not stop until all hostages are returned.

Endless bombings are no more “disproportional” than the hostage exchanges. Moreover, electricity must not be restored until all hostages are returned. Biblical Egypt was dark for three days. Gaza should remain dark for three years or decades if needed to recover the hostages. No electricity, no fuel, nothing but basic food and medical supplies forever until all hostages are returned.

14. And The Day After: How did this all happen, a terror project this well coordinated from so many vantage points? So many towns attacked at once, with missiles launched simultaneously? So: What of the vaunted Shin Bet? The Defense establishment?

They can torture Amiram Ben Uliel to get a confession. They can devote years to squeezing testimony to hurt Binyamin Netanyahu, even publicly exposing marital infidelities to shame state witnesses to get testimony against Bibi.

But they cannot keep Jewish women prison guards from sexually entertaining Arab mass murderers? And they could not anticipate this massively coordinated assault? When the exterminating ends, those heads must roll.

The weak and politically correct Defense Minister and Chief of Staff who devote more effort to tearing down new Jewish communities in Juda and Samaria than to tearing down illegal Arab structures in Area C. There must be a reckoning.

15. American public opinion? It does not matter what any other country thinks when Israel is fighting for its life. Nevertheless, understand: America now is in full “Election 2024” mode. There already have been two Republican presidential debates. The election will be between Biden and Trump. Everyone in America knows it, and no one in America can believe it or swallow it.

Politicians on both sides now are covering up everything they have done so as to clean their records for the voters. It is like how Bibi promises before every election to annex the Jordan Valley, and Bennett promised before his election never to sit with Yair Lapid. They all lie, especially during Election Season.

For the next 13 months, almost all American politicians will be firmly with Israel. The anti-Israel wing among America’s Democrats does not yet influence policy making. Ocasio, Rashida Tlaib, and Ilhan Omar make headlines but only represent, respectively, one small district of Bronx Puerto Ricans, one of Dearborn Arabs, and one of Minneapolis Somalians. They comprise less than one percent of the 435 Senators and Congressional representatives who make policy. Even with their cohort of lesser-public Zionist-Jew haters like Betty McCollum, Cori Bush, and Jaaal Bowman, they comprise three or four percent total. Biden is behind in many polls right now and cannot afford to criticize Israel.

America’s Christian voters read our Bible and will stand by Israel against Arab Muslims. Jews should, too. Know where to put faith: Only put faith in G-d. He guided Truman and Stalin to recognize Israel in 1948. He guided DeGaulle in 1956, Johnson in 1967, Nixon in 1973, and Trump. He will guide whom He will guide, and He will destroy whom he will destroy.

16.Finally: Netanyahu. He has been the mastermind of “Mowing the Grass.” Really, if not for (i) all the anti-Bibi protests outside Balfour when he last was prime minister, and (ii) the 40 weeks and 27 Million Shekels of disgusting civil insurrection and treasonous military refusals to report, and (iii) the despicably anti-democratic Supreme Court, and (iv) the viciously venomous years-long kangaroo charges aimed at forcing him out of office simply because he got cigars and champagne from a friend to feed his and his wife’s hedonistic side, and (v) all the Jew-hating Arabs and leftist Jews in Israel and American who hate Bibi, this should be his “Boris Johnson Moment.”

He deserves to be pressured right after the war to step down. He deserves it, but the thing is: his opponents do not deserve it. So he stays. For now.

Friday, October 6, 2023

ARABS IN THE UAE SAID THIS ABOUT JEWS, AND ISRAEL-HATERS CAN’T BELIEVE IT

 Is peace between Arabs and Jews possible? It most definitely is. Arabs in the UAE are looking forward to a bright future with Jews.

UAE Arabs Want Peace

This is truly amazing. A few decades ago, no one could have imagined something like this happening. Even just a few years ago this seemed like a crazy idea! But times are changing! The fact that Arabs in the UAE are not only feeling positive about peace with Israel but also willing to publicly say it is mind-blowing.

Many people don’t like former President Donald Trump. But those people have to give credit where credit is due. Trump was the one who helped bring about the Abraham Accords. This was a major accomplishment. It opened up the doors for many more positive developments between Israel and Arab countries.

The messages from these Arabs in the UAE are not just “I will try to tolerate you as a Jew.” These Emiratis are not being forced to make peace. They want to actively befriend Jews! The messages are about unity and love. The Arabs speaking here are really saying remarkable things. And it can only lead to more light in this world.

Peace between Arabs and Jews is possible. It is more than possible – it has already begun. No one benefits from all of the hate and bloodshed. Even the Arabs don’t benefit. Let’s pray that more Arabs wake up to the truth about the Jewish people and end their extreme hatred of the people of Israel.


Yom Kippur’s Tel Aviv Jew-haters embody a strange Biblical verse God allows purveyors of iniquity to bloom in seeming victory, but it is a pyrrhic victory. They have shown their true colors

 


 



 

Yom Kippur’s Tel Aviv Jew-Haters
Embody a Strange Biblical Verse

G-d allows purveyors of iniquity to bloom in seeming victory, but it is a pyrrhic victory. They have shown their true colors.Op-ed.



Sep 26, 2023, 6:19 PM (GMT+3)

There is a seemingly strange verse that Jewish worshippers (the ones who do not break up public Yom Kippur prayer services in Tel Aviv) recite. It appears in a psalm dedicated to the Shabbat day, Psalm 92: “While evildoers spring up like the grass, and the workers of iniquity blossom, it is so that they shall be destroyed forever.” 92:8.

What does that mean? If they are blooming, it seems they are coming into strength. Doesn’t that make them more dangerous? How does their sprouting foreshadow their eternal destruction?

Look at what is happening with the treasonous Ehud Barak Front and the nine months of weekly leftist demonstrations that break laws and close down parts of Tel Aviv every week at a cost of over $100,000 per “spontaneous demonstration.” Recall that each “spontaneous demonstration” entails paying the cost of setting up expensive platform staging and sound systems that carry clear transmissions to tens of thousands of people. Each “spontaneous” weekly demonstration entails hiring scores upon scores of buses to transport the “spontaneous” demonstrators. It entails tens of thousands of dollars to pay salaries to otherwise-unemployed full-time “spontaneous” demonstrators to be at the ready every week. It entails massive advertising.

This is so expensive that it even emerged in the media that the Israeli Left has been holding massively expensive fundraising dinners in the United States to raise hundreds of thousands dollars more to keep the “spontaneous” demonstrations going as long as it takes until Ehud Barak finally gets to see some of that blood in the streets or bodies floating in his nearest body of water, whether in the Kineret, the Yarkon, the Dead Sea, or Jeffrey Epstein Island. 
 

MIDA reports that some $10 million (27 million shekels) has been pumped into keeping the weekly anti-Israel “De-mo-krat-yah” “spontaneous” rallies afloat:

The budgets collected by the NGO [are] intended for “buses, stages, signs, flags, amplification equipment and screens, safety and authority approvals, branded clothing and more”, for “special projects – demonstrations in front of the houses of members of the Knesset, marches and the Democracy Outpost in Jerusalem, the shutdown of the economy”, and to “put banners balconies, bridges and billboards across the country.” For these purposes, the association has raised more than NIS 27 million in recent months.

Nevertheless, here is what is finally beginning to happen after nine months of this garbage: The “spontaneous” demonstrators are getting bored and disheartened. They have not achieved their key goals after nearly a year. They are no closer to bringing down the government or breaking Simcha Rotman or Yariv Levin. Bezalel Smotrich still is Finance Minister with his fingers also all over a massive expansion of Judea and Samaria community legalizing and construction permitting. Maybe it is not enough for those of us who would like to see even more, but there is nothing more heartening than each new public report issued by Left Wing Israeli organizations, and of course given massive leftist mainstream media coverage, that Israel is building more in Judea and Samaria than ever before.

Itamar Ben-Gvir still is a minister in the government. One day he wants to take away luxuries from Arab prisoners. Another day to cut down on their shower time. Another day to cut down on family visits. He wants a national guard under his control, threatens to bring down Bibi if Netanyahu trades Jewish land for a Saudi kaffiyeh. After nine months, the Leftists have been unable to dislodge Ben-Gvir. Nine months of hundred-thousand-dollar-a-week “spontaneous” demonstrations, and they have not accomplished a doggone thing except putting the judicial reform on hold, but that was not really their goal.

There is only one word that truly describes such extraordinary ineffectiveness, such waste of millions of leftist dollars, nine months of screaming and yelling and blocking Yarkon Highway — and accomplishing absolutely nothing. You know what that one word is to describe a movement that has spent ten million dollars to accomplish nothing?

Bushah. Shame.

What a bushah, what incompetence, what waste, what uselessness!

This nine-month testament to ineffectiveness is prompting the Left to show its first signs of beginning to crack. The “spontaneous” rallies are not cutting it. The first cracks are now showing, and they are getting more desperate. You see it everywhere. They get Air Force reservists to say they won’t serve, but so many more are on record signing petitions saying they will serve. And everyone knows that, if G-d forbid there is a real war, they all will serve because Nasrallah and Iran and Hamas will be shooting missiles at their homes, too, and their mothers’ and fathers’ and sisters’ and brothers’ homes. And their wives’ and sons’ and daughters’ and grandparents’ homes.
 

So they will be back in their fighter aircraft faster than a speeding bullet. The thing is, some of them will be a bit rusty, just as I was when I had not driven my car for nine months after being hospitalized to get a lung transplant. As a driver of forty-plus years it took me an hour or two to get reacquainted with all the gears and night traffic when I first got behind the wheel after nine months laid up in a hospital bed and then a wheelchair. But it was not terribly dangerous for me to need that hour or two because traffic moves so slowly on the 405 Freeway in Los Angeles that it is faster just to walk from Los Angeles to San Diego.

The thing is, some of these brave “spontaneous” treasonous air force reservists, who surely will race like crazy to get into their aircraft to defend their families and their homes if Nasrallah strikes, may find that, by skipping regular reserve duty when they were called, they have become rusty, and they may find that, with Iran and Nasrallah up in the sky against them, they do not have the luxury of two hours to refresh their readiness, and may end up getting themselves killed. So there is that. And that would be unforgivable, considering the millions Israel spend to train them.
 

Meanwhile, the Left is getting itchy. Their efforts are not working. So they show signs of desperation. They have now begun taking their fight to America, something no other country’s malcontents do. And they themselves never would have done that six months ago. But they are not seeing fruits. Therefore, suddenly they harass MK Simcha Rotman in Manhattan and Prime Minister Netanyahu at the U.N., sharing space with other anti-Netanyahu demonstrators who back Hamas and Iran. By doing so, they still accomplished nothing. Bibi still made excellent headlines with a brilliant one-on-one schmooze with Elon Musk viewed by millions on social media. He spoke at the UN and had a successful American visit.
 

 

 



And, frankly, it was exciting to see so many shameless Israeli anti-Israel demonstrators yelling “Bushah” in Manhattan. First, any regular New Yorker passing by and hearing “Bushah, Bushah” figured these were demented homeless maniacs (one of New York City’s larger demographic groups) or illegal Hispanic immigrants (another large city population group), in this case demonstrating hysterically against George W. Bushah, unaware that there are no more upper-echelon George Bushes to go around for now. And second, it is heartening to know they are in America, where they can scream but cannot vote, rather than in Israel. That may be several leftist seats wasting away in America.

Good.
 

 

 

And now, even more desperate that nothing is working, the Left is getting even more violent and hateful, attacking Yom Kippur prayers. For this, one has to go back to Stalin’s KGB and Hitler’s Stormtroopers for historical points of reference. This is important. For too many middle-of-the-road Israelis, there is an uncertainty now as to which side is more evil: the coalition side for court reform — because endless mass media falsehoods leave the “undecideds” confused — or the opposition who obviously stand for evil.
 



Well, not obvious to everyone, only to those of us who can read between the headlines and analyze how media distort the truth. We are those who note that a Ron Huldai never would dare forbid Muslims from worshipping with partitions separating genders, and we are grateful that our, uh, “cousins” have made circumcision a core rite of theirs, or Huldai conceivably would ban that, too. And we do hope the Jerusalem municipality gets the memo: if traditional Yom Kippur services are to be banned on the public streets of Tel Aviv out of deference to the municipal population’s preferences, then let “Pride Parades” be banned in Jerusalem on the exact same basis — or re-routed through Arab neighborhoods like Shuafat, Silwan, and “Sheikh Jarrah.”

And that is the explanation of the Biblical verse in Psalm 92:8. There comes a point when G-d decides He has had enough of the evildoers and needs to change the paradigm. So, in His infinite mercy and wisdom, He allows the purveyors of iniquity to bloom and to sprout, to blossom seemingly in unbridled victory. But it is a false bloom and pyrrhic victory. What actually is happening is that the perpetrators of evil are being lulled into showing their true colors, who and what the extremsts among them really are. They are not about the waving of Israeli flags and shouts of “De-mo-krat-yah.” Rather, they are enemies of Judaism itself. They hate the essence of Judaism. They hate Yom Kippur. They hate prayer to the G-d of Israel in the way Jews have prayed for 3,300 years. Their predecessors were the worshippers of Ba’al whom Elijah the Prophet dispatched in Mount Carmel and of the Sadducees of Talmudic times.

They now have shown themselves in full sprout. By so doing, they have brought enormous shame to themselves and have hastened their descent. “Undecideds” now finally can start getting a good look at them. Their slogan and motto is their eternal destiny:

Bushah. Shame.

And so 5784 begins.

 

To receive Rav Fischer’s Weekly Extensive Torah Commentaries or to attend any or all of Rav Fischer’s weekly 60-minute live Zoom classes on the Weekly Torah Portion, the Biblical Prophets, the Mishnah, Rambam Mishneh Torah, or Advanced Judaic Texts, send an email to: shulstuff@yioc.org

Wednesday, October 4, 2023

JRA Loudspeaker - A Conversation with Rabbi Dov Fischer - Jewish Republican Alliance


Rav Fischer’s recent hour-long interview on a range of pressing contemporary Jewish issues, ranging from the “Palestine” Fraud to incorrigible Jewish leftists and their like-minded reform rabbis to the weakness of pro-Israel campus Jews who root their advocacy in Victimology instead of Jewish strength

Monday, September 21, 2020

 Why David HaMelech Was Not Allowed to Build the Bais Hamikdosh (and the Broken Step of “Ichpis Darga” & “Darga Sevir”) by Baruch C. Cohen, Esq., in honor of the 21st Yahrtzeit of his father HaRav Shmuel Yisroel ben HaRav Meir HaKohein


1. Rav Pappa Stumbles on the Broken Step - “Darga Sevir”

There’s an interesting and fascinating Gemarah in Bava Basra 10a, that at first blush appears like a mere story of man on a ladder, but upon the second blush, we see that story is loaded with powerful symbolism and meaning that relates the following: 

Rav Pappa Havah Salek BeDarga Rav Pappa was once climbing up a ladder, Ishtamit Kareiy, when his foot slipped, Ba-ee LeMayfal he almost fell. Amar, Hashta Kein Achayiv Man DeSani Lan! He said to himself, I must be liable like one who Hashem hates!

Rav Pappa immediately began an internal audit of his sins (being Yefashfesh Bemaasav) by saying that the kind of heavenly death (Min Hashamayim) that he narrowly averted was one usually reserved for idolators (Ovdei Avodah Zarah) and murderers (Rotzchim) and seemed to panic over his fate. 

2. Chiyya bar Rav of Difti’s Novel Suggestion

In order to mitigate the severity of Rav Pappa's self-judgement, the Gemarah relates that Chiyya bar Rav of Difti said to Rav Pappa: Shemah Ani Bah LeYadcha Velo ParnaSaso perhaps a poor person once approached you and you did not sustain him (and therefore you were given a glimpse of the punishment that you actually deserve by slipping on the ladder). 

But where did Reb Chiyya divine and dream up (Yiddish “Cholomzuch”) the notion that Rav Pappa’s slipping on the ladder was attributed to the sin of not giving charity? There’s many sins and Aveiros that one could have done, how did Reb Chiya dream up that particular Aveirah? And what is the connection between the ladder of Rav Pappa and giving charity?

3. The Vilna Gaon’s Fascinating Remez of “Darga Sevir”

It’s said in the name of the Vilna Gaon (the GR’A)(1720-1797), in the Sefer Peninim MiShulchan HaGra, that in the Parsha of Reeh, (15:7-8) the Torah says:

Ki Yihyeh BeCha Evyon if there is among you a needy man, MeyAchad Achechah from among your brothers, BeAchad Shearecha BeArtzecha within your gates in your land, Lo SeAmetz es Levavecha do not harden your heart, Velo Sikpotz ed Yadecha MeAchecha HaEvyon and you shall not close you hand from your needy brother,  Ki Pasoach Tiftach Es Yadcha Lo, rather, you shall open your hand to him, VeHaabit Tavitenu Dai Machsero Asher Yechser Lo and you shall lend him sufficient for his needs, which he is lacking. 

This Possuk presents the source of the Mitzvah of giving Tzedakah.

According to the GRA, if you look at the musical cantillation, (Trop) of “Ki PasSoach Tiftach “ it is a Darga Sevir which in Aramaic means, Darga - step, and Sevir - break ie., a broken step (in fact, the Trop of the Darga looks like steps). In other words, this is a hint (Remez), that the punishment for not opening up one’s wallet for the needy sufficiently, will be a broken step under your feet.

4. “Ichpis Dargah” - the Broken Stair of David HaMelech

There’s a fascinating Gemarah in Shabbos 30b:

What did David HaMelech mean when he said in Tehillim 39:5: Hodieyni Hashem Kitzai, Umidos Yamai Ma Hi, Eydah Mah Chadal Ani?

The Gemarah in Shabbos explains that it means that David HaMelech said before Hashem: Master of the Universe, Hodieyni Hashem Kitzai Lord, make me to know my end; in how long will I die? Hashem said to him: Gezeirah Hi Milfanai SheAyn Modiin Kitzo Shel Basar Vadam - There is a Heavenly decree (Gezeirah) not to reveal to a person the end of the life of flesh and blood. 

David HaMelech asked further: Umidos Yamai Ma Hi and the measure of my days; on what day of the year will I die? Hashem responded: Gezeirah Hi Milfanai SheAyn Modiin Midas Yamav Shel Adam - it is decreed before Me not to reveal the measure of a person’s days. 

Again David HaMelech requested: Eydah Mah Chadal Ani let me at least know how short-lived I am; on what day of the week will I die? Hashem responded: BeShabbos Tamus - you will die on Shabbos. 

David HaMelech requested of Hashem: Amus Be’Echad BeShabbos Let me die after Shabbos on the following Sunday (so that the honor of Shabbos will not be tarnished by the pain of my death). Hashem said to him: Kvar Higiyah Malchus Shlomo Beno on that day the time of the kingdom of your son Shlomo has already arrived, VeAyn Malchus Nogaas BaChavartah Afilu KiMlo Nimah - and one kingdom does not overlap with another and subtract or infringe from the time allotted to another even a hairbreadth. 

David HaMelech said to Hashem: Amus BeErev Shabbos I will cede a day of my life and die on Erev Shabbos. Hashem declined David HaMelech’s offer to die one day ealrier on Erev Shabbos Ki Tov Yom BeChatzirecha MeyElef for a day in your court is better than a thousand (Tehillim 84:11) Tov Li Echad ShAtah Yosheiv VeOsek BaTorah Mayelef Olos SheAsid Shlomo Bincha LeHakriv Lifnei Al Gabei HaMizBeach a single day in which you sit and engage in Torah is preferable to Me than the thousand burnt-offerings that your son Shlomo will offer before Me on the altar.

The Gemarah in Shabbos continues:

So what did David HaMelech do? Kol Yomah DeShabta Haveh Yasiv VeGares Kulei Yoma every Shabbos he would sit and learn all day long (to protect himself from the Angel of Death (Malach Hamoves)). Hahu Yomeh DeBai LeMeynach Nafshei on that day on which the Angel of Death was supposed to put his soul to rest (the day on which David HaMelech was supposed to die), Kam Malach HaMaves Kamei the Angel of Death stood before him, Velo Yachil Ley and was unable to overcome him, DeLa Havah Paseik Pumei MiGirsah  because his mouth did not pause from the study of Torah. Amar May A-Avid Lei the Angel of Death said: What shall I do to him? Havah Lei Bustana Achorei Baisah David HaMelech had a garden behind his house; Asa Malach HaMaves Saleik Uvachish BeIlanei the Angel of Death came, climbed, and shook the trees. 

Nafak LeMichzei  David HaMelech went out to see, Hevi Salak BeDargah, as he climbed the stair, “Ichpis Dargah” the stair broke beneath him. He was startled and was silent, interrupted his studies for a moment, and died. 

So how did David HaMelech die? “Ichpis Dargah” the stair broke beneath him. 

So it would appear, from the Vilna Gaon, based on the Gemarah in Bava Basra, that Rav Pappa’s slipping on the steps was attributed to him not giving charity, as deduced by the Trop of Dargeh Sevir the broken step. So one might therefore extrapolate a fascinating connection between David Hamelech’s slipping on his step, the Ichpis Dargah the stair broke beneath him, and the sin of not giving enough charity via the Trop of Dargeh Sevir the broken step.

Now we have to put this in proper context. David HaMelech was an enormous Baal Tzedakah, as reported in the Gemarah in Bava Basra 10b: 

"R. Abbahu also said: Shlomo the son of David was asked: Ad Heychan Kochah Shel Tzedaka how far does the power of charity extend? He replied: TzeU UreU Mah Piresh David Aba go and see what my father David has stated on the matter: Pazar Nosan LeEvyonim Tzidkaso Omedes LawAd Karno Tarum BeChovod he has dispersed, he has given to the needy, his righteousness endures forever (Tehillim 112:4).’"  

So how are we to understand this? Hold that thought, place a bookmark right here, and we shall return to it. 

5. Two Conflicting Reasons Why David HaMelech Was Not Allowed to Build the Bais HaMikdosh

To add to our dilemma, let us now analyze a seeming contradiction in the Torah as to why David HaMelech was not allowed to build the Bais HaMikdosh.

a. Reason # 1: David HaMelech Had Blood in His Hands “Dam LaRov Shafachta”

We see in Divrei Hayamim I 22:7-8, (Chronicles), that David HaMelech prepared the plans for the construction of the Bais HaMikdosh: David HaMelech said to his son Shlomo, 

“My son, I wanted to build the Bais HaMikdosh, but Hashem came to me, saying, Dam LaRov Shafachta You have shed much blood, Umilchemes Gedolos Asisah and fought great battles; Lo Sivneh Bayis Lishmi you shall not build a House for My name, Ki Damim Rabim Shafachta Artzah Lefanai for you have shed much blood on the earth in My sight: Behold a son will be born to you… Shlomo will be his name… He shall build the Bais Hamikdosh in My Name. 

And thus, because David HaMelech was not allowed to build the Bais HaMikdosh, he instead prepared everything for its construction. 

However, if you think about it, so what if David HaMelech spilled a lot of blood, wasn’t he waging war per Hashem’s directives? Wasn’t his battles sanctioned by Hashem (Milchemes Mitzvah)? Can one who performs the Mitzvah of circumcision (Milah) not build the Bais Hamikdosh because he’s got blood on his hands? His blood is from the Mitzvah of Milah? It’s Dam Mitzvah? And who did David HaMelech kill? He killed our enemy Amalek, the Sonei Yisroel. David HaMelech’s battles were a Milchemes Mitzvah. So why couldn’t he build the Bais Hamikdosh? So what if he’s got blood on his hands?

In fact, HaRav Ovadia Yosef (Teshuvos Yechaveh Daas 2:14) grappled with the Halachic question of whether Kohanim who fought in Israel’s wars and killed soldiers from the opposing side, could still serve as Kohanim and Duchen and bless Klal Yisroel. Specifically, HaRav Ovadia Yosef ruled, that in the case of Israeli Chayal soldiers who killed enemy soldiers in a defensive war where Kohanim IDF soldiers risked their lives to confront the enemy and to save Jewish lives, it is proper to tell these soldiers ‘Yeyasher Kochachem’ and ‘May your hands be strengthened.’  HaRav Ovadia Yosef wrote: that the matter is clear beyond any shadow of a doubt that these IDF Kohanim are eligible and worthy of Nesias Kapayim, and they should be blessed from the One above.” 

If anything, David HaMelech should specifically (BeDavkah) build the Bais HaMikdosh because he cleared out Eretz Yisroel from the enemies of the Jewish People. What’s the big deal that he had blood on his hands?

b. Reason # 2: David HaMelech Didn’t Give (Enough) Tzedakah 

If we look elsewhere in Divrei Hayamim  I 22:14 we see that David HaMelech said: 

VeHinei BeAni in my poverty, See, by denying myself, I have laid aside for the Bais HaMikdsosh, Zahav Kikarim Meah Elef 100,000 Kikar talents of gold, VeKesef Elef Alafim Kikarim and 1,000,000 talents of silver, and so much copper and iron it cannot be weighed; I have also laid aside wood and stone, and you shall add to them.” 

David HaMelech had literally billions of dollars prepared for the Bais HaMikdosh that he claimed he held in his poverty (BeAni). 

The Midrash Yalkut Shemoni on Divrei Hayamim I 22:14 asks, could a poor man have so much money? Where did David HaMelech get so much money?  He explains that on the day he killed Golias, Jewish women threw their silver and gold at David, and he gathered it and dedicated it for the Bais HaMikdosh. Meaning that VeHinei BeAni he was still impoverished because he didn’t keep the money for himself and designated and sanctified it as Holy Money (Momon Hekdesh) and saved it for the building of the Bais HaMikdsosh.

The Midrash Yalkut Shemoni continues that one day, David HaMelech decided to take a census of the Jewish population of his kingdom. He ordered Yoav, the general of his army, to count the nation. Now, every Jewish schoolchild knows that you don’t count the Jewish People—it’s just not allowed. But David HaMelech, despite Yoav’s petitions to the contrary, insisted that the Jewish Nation be counted. And as a result of that, a plague struck the Jewish Nation, in addition to a famine that lasted for three years during the reign of David HaMelech. Now, at that same time, David HaMelech had stores of silver and gold that had been designated for the Bais HaMikdosh, and he should have withdrawn them and used them to feed the people, but he did not do so. 

This angered Hashem Who said to him, 

“My Children are dying by famine and you’re collecting money to build a building with?!  I swear that you will not merit building the Bais Hamikdosh, and it will be your son Shlomo to build it, and Shlomo will have no need for that money whatsoever!” (Midrash, Yalkut Shimoni Chap. 186.)  

In other words, David HaMelech had an endowment fund set up with which to build the Bais HaMikdosh, and he invested all of his soul into it. Suddenly, he now had a devastating famine on his hands, and the people needed money to survive. And I’m sure David HaMelech had his reasons not to touch the money that he had dedicated for the Bais HaMikdosh—he perceived it as belonging to the Bais HaMikdosh, not him, and so he did not use it.

But Hashem disagreed, with David HaMelech’s reasons and held that it didn’t matter how important the Bais HaMikdosh was—feeding people was more important than any construction project you may have; even than the Bais HaMikdosh! (as it says in the Gemarah Yerushlami Peah 88a, Mitzvas Tzedakah LeAniyim Yoser MiBinyan Bais HaMikdosh - that giving Tzedakah is greater Mitzvah than building the Bais HaMikdash)

So here we see that David HaMelech was the richest man on earth, he had the richest treasury at his disposal, yet and at the same time he was the poorest man, because he denied himself access to these funds. And when the 3-year famine came, he didn’t give Klal Yisroel the monies that he collected. So it appears that Hashem felt that David HaMelech had his priorities wrong and miscalculated, because Hashem had said Tzedakah is greater than the building of the Bais HaMikdosh. Therefore David HaMelech was punished by not being allowed to build the Bais HaMikdosh.

So it appears that we have a contradiction (Stirah), as to why David HaMelech couldn’t build the Bais Hamikdosh. Was it because (Reason #1) he killed a lot of people and was a warrior with blood on his hands, or was it because (Reason #2) he didn’t give Tzedakah and support the people?

6. Reb Yonasan Eibeschitz’s Brilliant Resolution

The Gemarah in Brachos 3b describes David HaMelech’s daily learning schedule. David HaMelech wrote in Tehillim 119:62: Chatzos Laylah Akum Lehodos Lecho,  “At midnight I rise to give thanks for Your righteous laws,” meaning that David HaMelech rose at midnight, two watches before dawn, in order to study Torah. David HaMelech had a sign indicating when it was midnight. A harp suspended over David’s bed, and once midnight arrived, the northern midnight wind would come and cause the lyre to play on its own. David would immediately rise from his bed and study Torah until the first rays of dawn. 

Once dawn arrived, the Sages of Israel entered to advise him with regard to the various concerns of the nation and the economy. 

They said to him: Adoneinu HaMelech Our master, the king, Amcha Yisroel Tzrichin Parnassah your nation requires sustenance, they need money. David HaMelech answered them Lechu VehiParsu Zeh MiZeh let them do business with one another, and so they will earn their money.  The Chachamim further answered him with a parable: Ain HaKometz Masbiah Es HaAri a single handful of food does not satisfy a lion, VeAiyn HaBor MisMaleh MayChulyaso and a pit will not be filled (merely from the rain that falls directly into its mouth but other water must be piped in). So too, the nation cannot sustain itself using its own resources. In other words, David HaMelech, your system is not working and the nation cannot sustain itself using its own resources. 

So David HaMelech advised them to Lechu Upishtu Yedeiychem Bigedud go and take up arms with the troops in battle in order to expand our borders and provide our people with the opportunity to earn a livelihood, to capture the thieves and that will solve the problem. (ie., war is good for the economy, so go fight a war, plunder and raise the necessary funds to support yourself. 

On the one hand, we have the Divrei Hayamim I 22:7-8 that says that he could not build the Bais HaMikdosh because he had blood on his hands Dam LaRov Shafachta; and on the other hand, we have the Gemarah in Brachos 3b that concludes that he could not build the Bais HaMikdosh because he didn’t want to give up of his treasury of all the gold and silver that the Jewish women threw at him after killing Golias, and didn’t share his wealth and give Tzedakah and support the Jewish People during the 3-year famine. So which reason was it?

Reb Yonoson Eibeschitz (5450-5524; 1690-1764) says in his Sefer Ya'aros Devash, that this Gemarah  in Brachos 3b actually unlocks the mystery as to why David HaMelech couldn’t build the Bais Hamikdosh. According to Reb Yonoson Eibeschitz, both were correct. 

David HaMelech had a lot of money stored up in his treasury, and could have supported Klal Yisroel in their greatest time of need, but instead, he told them to go wage a permissible war (Milchemes Reshus), not an obligatory war (Milchemes Mitzvah). Had David HaMelech’s advice to go wage war to generate income been an obligatory war (Milchemes Mitzvah), it would not have invalidated him to build the Bais HaMikdosh, because his actions would have been immunized by the mere fact that his battle was an obligatory war (Milchemes Mitzvah). The reason of Dam LaRov Shafachta that his hands shed much blood would not have been the reason. But since those wars were due to David HaMelech’s rationalization not to give Tzedakah, said wars were not a Milchemes Mitzvah, but rather were a permissible war  (Milchemes Reshus), that is why he was punished by Hashem that he couldn’t build the Bais HaMikdosh.

Hashem basically told David HaMelech, “I don’t want your money” (to build the Bais HaMikdosh). It wasn’t because Dam LaRov Shafachta that your hands were full of blood from being a warrior in battle of an obligatory war (Milchemes Mitzvah), but that Dam LaRov Shafachta your hands were full of blood because you didn’t come through with financial support when Klal Yisroel needed it most and he instead sent them off on an unnecessary battle of a permissible war (Milchemes Reshus).

Now we know why David HaMelech died with a fall from the broken step (Ichpis Darah), as he neglected the poor when they needed his money. Chiyya bar Rav of Difti’s answer to Rav Pappa was also correct, that not giving Tzedakah can be the cause for slipping off a step, therefore he got the Vilna Gaon’s insight into the Trop of Darga Sevir broken step as his final death blow. 

And now we know why David HaMelech was not allowed to build the Bais HaMikdosh, because both reasons are correct; he didn’t give (enough) charity to Klal Yisroel during the 3-year famine, and because Dam LaRov Shafachta he had blood on his hands, and because the wars that he instructed the Jewish People to wage were not necessary (Milchemes Mitzvah), but were permissive and optional (Milchemes Reshus).

7. David HaMelech’s Foot Slipped - “Im Amarti Matah Ragli” 

Parenthetically, we find David HaMelech’s foot slipping elsewhere. There is a fascinating reference to this elsewhere, as we say in the Shir Shel Yom for Wednesdays, David HaMelech says in Tehillim 94:18: 

Im Amarti Matah Ragli if I said,  my foot has slipped, Chasdecha Hashem Yisadeini Your kindness, O Lord, supported me. 

When we wrap ourselves in the Tallis in the morning Shacharis we say: 

Ma Yakar Chasdecha Elokhim, Uv’nei Adam B’tzeil K’nafecha Yechesayun How precious is Your kindness, O G d! The children of men take refuge in the shadow of Your wings. 

The Chofetz Chaim’s Sefer Ahavas Chesed, 2:2, says that we awaken the Chesed of Hashem, when we do Chesed. That it’s Midah Keneged Middah, Bo Ureay, Kocho Shel Baaley Tzedakah VeGomlei Chesed, SheNemar, Mah Yakar Chasdecha Elokim...  That we can trigger Hashem’s Heavenly Chesed to us, by us doing Chassadim for others, and in that merit,  B’tzeil K’nafecha Yechesayun, we take refuge in the shadow of Hashem’s wings.

Perhaps David HaMelech was saying: Im Amarti Matah Ragli if I see that my foot has slipped, meaning that I didn’t give enough Tzedakah, and deserved to be punished, then Chasdecha Hashem Yisadeini, it’s only Your Chesed, Hashem, that sustains me.

This is all an amazing revelation that the Vilna Gaon teaches us about Rav Pappa, which ties into the Yalkut Shimoni that David HaMelech couldn’t build the Bais HaMikdosh because he didn’t want to support the poor with his money for the Bais HaMikdosh, that resulted in the fate of the broken steps of David HaMelech’s Ichpis Dargah, and Rav Pappa’s Dargah Sevir, which perhaps can explain what David HaMelech meant when he said  Im Amarti Matah Ragli Chasdecha Hashem Yisadeini.

8. Conclusion - Tzedakah Maavirin Es Roah HaGezeirah

During the Yomim Noraim, we say: Teshuva, Tefillah, UTtzedakah Maavirin es Roah HaGezeirah that repentance, prayer and giving charity will remove the decree.

Let us take heed of the powerful lessons of the broken step of Rav Pappa via the Vilna Gaon’s Trop of the Dargah Sevir, let us remember the broken step of David Hamelech, the Ichpis Dargah, and let us strengthen our resolve to be charitable. And while we clench our fists and beat our hearts to repent and do Teshuvah on Yom Kippur when we say Vidui, let us now unclench our fists and open our hands and turn away no one who’s hand is outreached to us for Tzedakah, that in that awesome merit (Zechus) of our renewed commitment to charitable giving,  Maavirin es Roah HaGezeirah the decrees against us will be removed. 

Let us also remember that Im Amarti Matah Ragli, and when we try to do our best in life, but our feet slip, we stumble and falter, that Chasdecha Hashem Yisadeini, that Hashem will still recognize and acknowledge our efforts, and will reciprocate and shower us with His Chassadim, and blessings via Mah Yakar Chasdecha Elokim that how precious is Hashem’s kindness, that B’tzeil K’nafecha Yechesayun, we will always take refuge in the shadow of Hashem’s wings.

In that merit, may we be merit (Zoche) that Hashem will see our modest attempts to improve our lives during the Aseres Yemei Teshuvah, and provide us with Siyata Dishmaya and enable us to return to Him BeTshuvah Shleimah, and may we be Zoche to emerge from the Yom HaDin with a Kesivah VaChasimah Tovah. 

Friday, February 28, 2020

BCC schmoozing with his cousin, Rabbi Yaakov Yosef Hager, son of the Vizhnitzer Rebbe of Monsey and son-in-law of the Skverer Rebbe of New Square NY, at the Los Angeles reception of Mosdos Vizhnitz.

Image may contain: one or more people and beard

BCC schmoozing with his cousin, Rabbi Yaakov Yosef Hager, son of the Vizhnitzer Rebbe of Monsey and son-in-law of the Skverer Rebbe of New Square NY, at the Los Angeles reception of Mosdos Vizhnitz.

BCC’S mother's Chassidic lineage intersects and stems from Rabbi Chaim Hager of Ottynia (the Tal Chaim) (1863-1931) who was a brother of Rabbi Yisroel Hager, the 3rd Rebbe of Vizhnitz (the Ahavas Yisroel) (1860-1936); who was the son of Rabbi Baruch Hager, the 2nd Rebbe of Vizhnitz (the Imrei Baruch) (1845-1892); who was the son of Rabbi Menachem Mendel Hager, the 1st Rebbe of Vizhnitz (the Tzemach Tzadik) (1830-1884) (son in law of Yisroel of Ruzhin); who was the son of Rabbi Chaim Hager of Kosov (the Toras Chaim); who was the son of Rabbi Menachem Mendel Hager of Kosov (the Ahavas Shalom); who was the son of Rabbi Yaakov Koppel Likover (disciple of the Baal Shem Tov)

Photo credit Rabbi Yisrael Gelb

(Think about it: but for, WWII, BCC would probably be looking just like his Chassidisher cousins)


1. My Grandfather, Rabbi Baruch Hager, zt'l   (1899-1942).

My mother's father was Rabbi Baruch Hager of Horodenka, ABD Cozmeni, Bukovina from 1936 and then Dayan in Czernowitz, born in 1899 and died of typhus in the work camp in Warchovka, Transnitra Concentration Camp in 1941, married in 1922 to his first cousin Miriam, daughter of R. Shraga Feivel Hager of Zaleszczyki (Zalischik). He was very active in the Mizrachi movement and Zeire Mizrachi and was President of the Torah V’Avodah. She remarried in 1954/5 to R. Moshe Zvi Twersky, Admur Tolna-Philadelphia.

Rabbi Baruch Hager was the son of Rabbi Yechiel Michel Hager, Admur Horodenka from 1892 on his father’s death, born in 1872 and died of typhus in the work camp in Warchovka, Transnitra Concentration Camp in 1941 (as did his son Baruch), married his niece, Bluma Reizel, daughter of R. Haim Hager of Ottynia. He was one of the sons of the Imrei Baruch, he was appointed Rebbe (as were his brothers), after his father's petira on 20 Kislev 1892. Rav Yechiel Michel moved to Horodenka, to succeed his brother, Rav Shmuel Abba, who passed away childless in 1895. He married the daughter of his older brother, Rav Chaim (Rebbe in Antiniya). During World War I, he escaped to Chernowitz and served as Rebbe to the many Vizhnitz Chassidim there. He had one son, Baruch, who was later appointed Dayan in Chernowitz. After Sukkos of 1941, he was among 5000 Jews who were deported to Transnistria, and area in southwestern Ukraine, between the Dniester River ("Nistru" in Romanian) and the Bug River, north of the Black Sea. Also on that transport was Rav Aharon of Boyan, who came down with typhus and was niftar on 13 or 14 Cheshvan. Both Rav Yechiel Michel and his son Baruch came down with typhus in the work camp in Warchovka and died there.

2. My Great-Grandfather, Rabbi Yechiel Michel Hager of Horodenka, zt'l  (1872-1942).

Rabbi Yechiel Michel Hager was the son of Rabbi Baruch Hager, 2nd Vizhnitzer Rebbe (the "Imrei Baruch") and Zipora Hagar. His brothers were Rabbi Yisroel Hager, 3rd Vizhnitz Rebbe; R' Chaim Hager, Admur Ottynia (Itinia); R' Moshe Hager, Admur Shatz; R' Shmuel Abba Hager of Kolomyja-Horodenka; R' Yitzhak Yaakov Dovid Hager of Storozhinets-Vienna.     

3. My Great-Great Grandfather, Rabbi Baruch Hager, 2nd Vizhnitzer Rebbe, the "Imrei Baruch" was the son of Rabbi Menachem Mendel Hager, 1st Vizhnitzer Rebbe and Miriam Hager (1845-1892).

4. My Great-Great-Great Grandfather, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Hager, was 1st Vizhnitzer Rebbe (the "Tzemach Tzaddik") (1830-1884).

5. My Great-Great-Great-Great Grandfather, was Rabbi Chaim Hager of Kosow and Tzipora Hager (the ""Toras Chaim") (1795-1854).

6. My Great-Great-Great-Great-Great Grandfather, was Rabbi Menachem Mendel Hager, of Kosov (the "Ahavas Shalom") (1768-1825).


7. My Great-Great-Great-Great-Great-Great  Grandfather, was Rabbi Yacov-Kopel [Chassid of Kolomaya] Hager and Chaya Hager (1730-1787) and was a Talmid of the Baal Shem Tov.

Tuesday, February 25, 2020

Behaving like a Mentch

Behaving like a Mentch



Although I have never met him, Orthodox Los Angeles attorney Baruch Cohen and I have a shared experience that we would not wish on our worst enemy. We both lost children to a rare form of cancer known as Ewing’s Sarcoma. He a lost a daughter. I lost a grandson. I cannot even begin to imagine what it must be like to lose a child. The pain must be indescribable. But I can tell you that losing a grandchild is not easy either. (R’ Baruch talks about his personal experience in a Mishpacha Magazine  article.)

Thankfully we have more than just that in common. We both have an almost visceral hatred for Chilul HaShem. Especially the kind that is the result of poorly developed sense of ethics when it comes to the secular world in which we live. This has unfortunately manifested itself more times than I can count in recent years. So often that I have stopped counting.

More often than not this happens by way of cheating the government out of money. Whether it is laundering criminally obtained funds via an elaborate charity system; or avoiding federal taxes through inflated charitable donations – 90% of which are kicked back; or using funds the government earmarked for one thing for something else; or using other people’s social security numbers to divert payments to themselves… you name it. If there is a way to cheat the government, it has probably been tried.

I have written about many of these things and have condemned them all. They were legally wrong and the perpetrators knew it. But in some cases they saw nothing wrong with it morally and committed those crimes because they thought they could get away with. I recall one fellow I know who now sits in prison making an offhand remark that government clerks  manning the system are so ‘dumb’ that stealing from the government would be a near risk free enterprise. He found out that those clerks weren’t so dumb after all. And in fact they are a lot smarter than he is.

That said, fear of being caught should not be what motivates anyone from committing a crime. Even now where prison reform is a bit more favorable to those who commit those crimes. It ought to be our sense of morals and ethics… our fear of creating a Chilul HaShem. Not fear of getting caught.

This is where Jewish education seems to have failed. Let me hasten to add that I am not castigating every yeshiva or elementary school. I am absolutely convinced that many schools do teach ethics and try mightily to teach their students ethical behavior. That in fact was my own personal experience. I had many teachers like that and one in particular that was an exemplar of ethical and moral behavior in every respect. 

But I fear that are many instances where there has not been enough of that. Not at home where it should begin. And not in school. In fact there are some schools that practically teach the opposite. I recall listening to a recording of a Hashkafa Shiur where a Rebbe in a popular Yeshiva high school vilified virtually all non Jews to such an extent, that one might come out believing that it is practically a Mitzvah to take advantage of them in any way you could – as long as you didn’t get caught! It sickened me, to say the least!

This is where Baruch Cohen comes in. His Hashkafos are Charedi in the mold of the Chofetz Chaim Yeshiva. For which I have a soft spot. They are among the finest of Yeshivos - producing role models of behavior. Their students become Talmidei Chachamim with a highly developed sense of morals and ethics. I received the following note from him which speaks for itself: 

This past x-mas, I  had the opportunity... to address the Boys Division of Valley Torah High School  (VTHS) on “Killer Litigation Strategies for Lawsuits, Business and Life.” (Avoiding Chillul Hashems).  Below and enclosed is the the outline of the speech. It was based on many Youtube speeches that I heard by criminal defense attorney Ben Brafman on the issue.

I used various headlines of Chillul Hashem in the powerpoint presentation so that the boys and the rabbonim experience the "cringe factor."

It was a huge hit; the boys didn't want to leave afterwards and the hands were all raised with questions. This important topic totally gripped the audience. Your outstanding blog on this issue was a major inspiration.  

This was followed by another note which said the following: 

VTHS Dean and Rosh Yeshivah Rabbi Avrohom Stulberger said: "We need more voices like that of Baruch Cohen. Frum attorneys, yeshiva graduates, a talmid chochom to be role models to our kids. Too often it's only rabbonim who we look to as role models. We need more baal habatim who are shtark bnei torah to set examples to our kids. To know from the secular world, right from wrong. To speak from the trenches of the secular world, how to behave like a mentsch." 

And that was followed by still another note from R’ Baruch personally: 

Frum Baal habatim who have been koveah itim on a serious level all of our lives need to be seen as role models for our youth. Our society’s 2-tier system that the ideal is learning in kollel and the not-so-ideal is to work for a living is simply wrong and misguided. It turns off many and gives them an inferiority complex if they pursue honest parnassah that somehow they failed the system.  

Like I said, we have a lot in common. What he has done in LA should be the model adopted by all days schools and Yeshiva high schools. I hope that officials at Torah U’Mesorah are listening. What follow is the above-mentioned outline of his talk. 

1. The World Does Not like Jews - we do not need to encourage more people to dislike us

2. Wearing a Yarmulkeh - carries with it an extra measure of responsibility

3. We Must Be More Honest - more careful, more courteous & more prudent

4. When We Screw-Up, it Gets Magnified - the “Cringe Factor” (ie., Frum Slumlords)

5. Having Good Intentions Is Not a Legitimate Excuse - for Breaking the Law

6. Bad Behavior for a Good Cause - a lie for a good reason & a Mitzvah is still a lie

7. The US Government Is Not the Enemy - we’re not in Europe during WW-II8. We Cannot Pick & Choose the Rules We Live by - no smorgasbord Judaism 

Baruch Cohen’s 14 Rules for the American Orthodox Jew: 

1. Keep Your Word - do what you what you say you're going to do

2. Document Everything - confirm everything in writing

3. Follow the Rules - be a law-abiding citizen - know the laws - serve on a Jury

4. Don't Think You're Smarter than the Law & Won't Get Caught - you will 

5. You’re Not Right Because You’re Orthodox - you’re right because you’re honest

6. Establish Credibility  - admit when you're wrong

7. Listen to Your Internal Compass - if it sounds to good to be true, it is;

8. Consult Before Taking Action - not after

9.  Believe in Yourself, Act with Courage & Confidence - but never with arrogance

10. Stop Being Nosy - “but I’m just asking”

11. Give Unconditionally - with no expectation of anything in return

12. Insert Bais Din Arbitration Clauses in Your Contracts - believe in our Torah

13. Stand up for Judaism & Eretz Yisroel - never apologize about both

14. Pause, Before Pushing “Send” on Emails and Texts - it could save your life

BORN OF GRIEF, By Baila Rosenbaum | MISHPACHA MAGAZINE, DECEMBER 25, 2019

BORN OF GRIEF,  By Baila Rosenbaum | MISHPACHA MAGAZINE, DECEMBER 25, 2019

The Torah tells us that after the death of Aharon’s two sons, “Vayidom Aharon — and Aharon was silent.” “But what about his wife?” asks Baruch. How did she cope? What does the Torah tell us about her life after this tragedy?


It wasn’t so long ago that Baruch Cohen and his family, content New York transplants to Los Angeles, were living a life of innocence. Baruch ran a successful high-powered litigation law practice and the four Cohen children attended the local yeshivos and Bais Yaakov. A product of over six years of beis medrash and kollel, Baruch was kovei’a itim and his learning schedule included Mishnah Berurah yomi and the daf. Life was good.

He was going strong and two-and-a-half years into daf yomi when, within days of 9/11, the family’s upwardly mobile life experienced its own ground zero. The Cohens’ daughter, 15-year-old Hindy, was diagnosed with a pediatric cancer called Ewing’s sarcoma and the Cohens’ world changed irrevocably.

“I had to juggle an active law practice, we had to take care of our other children, deal with the emotional trauma of pediatric oncology, arrange medical care, babysitters, Chai Lifeline, Bikur Cholim — the works — while avoiding the gravitational pull of the black hole of anxiety, fear, and depression,” Baruch remembers. Though he was a very active learner before the crisis, his learning fell by the wayside as Hindy’s battle took center stage.

Hindy faced her illness with grace and courage, but succumbed after two-and-half-years, leaving the family bereft and grieving. Her passing demanded a new set of existential challenges for Baruch and would send him on a unique journey in his learning.

“During the shivah,” he remembers, “people would express meaningless clichés and drop platitudes that were almost repulsive to me. Phrases like ‘ein milim,’ there are no words. What did that mean? There is a word for everything in the Torah. Torah is timeless, it has messages for everybody. How could it be that there were no words in the Torah for a bereaved parent?”

Certain that there must be words in the vastness of Torah that would speak to his situation, Baruch set out to find them.

Back when Hindy had been healthy, Baruch had kept to a daily regimen of Gemara learning. During her illness, he dropped out of learning entirely. Now, after her tragic death, as he grappled with the new contours of his world of bereavement, his passion for learning was reignited — with a new focus on the weekly sedra.

When learning the parshah, Baruch found that he was listening through the ears of a bereaved parent. “A baal nisayon breathes different oxygen than everyone else. He processes things through a different lens. I was perceiving things differently and started learning Torah differently.”

Reading about Yaakov and Yosef’s reunion in Mitzrayim the mefarshim say that Yosef cried, but Yaakov did not cry. Rashi says he was reciting Krias Shema. “What I understood from that was, of course he couldn’t cry! He was hyperventilating. He was face to face with the son whose death he had mourned.”

Looking through what Baruch describes as “tainted lenses” led him on a quest to find an understanding of the Torah that would provide him with consolation, connection, and, ultimately, enlightenment. He started learning again — but differently, on his terms. “I reinvented myself,” he says.

He began to note every tragedy and researched the mefarshim to understand how Torah personalities coped with their challenges. Kayin killed Hevel, now Adam and Chavah were bereaved parents. What does the Torah tell us about how they reacted? Unlike material about grief and mourning available on the broader market, Baruch’s learning was on a level that resonated with the well-seasoned ben Torah and kollel avreich — using every commentary in the Mikraos Gedolos, the Midrash Rabbah, the Yalkut Shimoni, and other high-level sources, where he sought to discover how our forefathers coped with tragedy.

His studies expanded and he started researching gedolei Yisrael, reading their letters and seforim to discover how they coped with challenges. The result: a 500-page compilation of his writings, correspondences, and helpful articles he’s accumulated over the years, which he shares as chizuk for those in need, titled Reb Yochanon’s Bone: Chizuk for the Bereaved Parent (referred to by several gedolim as “the encyclopedia of nechamah”).

Baruch’s learning morphed into community-wide mussar vaadim (i.e., Shaar Habitachon of Chovos HaLevavos; Shaar Hasimchah and Shaar Ha’anavah of Orchos Tzaddikim; Shaar Hanekius of Mesillas Yesharim; and Bilvavi Mishkan Evneh) and a yearly public speech given on Hindy’s yahrtzeit in which he shares insights into grieving and healing. In these speeches, Baruch takes a topic that fascinates him and dives in. That means delving into myriad mefarshim, camping out in the kollel late at night, following leads, calling rabbanim, and attacking the issue like a legal researcher would.

The topics he chooses are not outside the mainstream, but they are beyond the typical perspective; he describes them as “the stuff wedged in between the cracks of the sidewalk, the space between the words, or the pause in between the musical notes.” For example, the Torah tells us that after the death of Aharon’s two sons, “Vayidom Aharon — and Aharon was silent.”

“But what about his wife?” asks Baruch. How did she cope? What does the Torah tell us about her life after this tragedy?

In another example, Baruch cites that a navi needs to be b’simchah when he receives and conveys a prophecy. So how, then, did Yirmiyahu write Eichah? He could not have been in a joyous state of mind when reliving the Churban! Most of us would never have thought of this question, but Baruch discovered that many others already have — including the Chazon Ish, Rav Yehonasan Eybeschutz, Yam Hamelach, and the Ben Ish Chai.

Questions like these coupled with Baruch’s exhaustive research have culminated in magnificent articles and presentations that Baruch shares, both by speaking publicly and in his writing. He is the author of Grieving and Healing in the Prism of Torah: Parents’ Spiritual Guide through Pain and Grief, a book devoted to bringing hope to the bereaved and help them reclaim happiness from tragedy.

Today Baruch is a steady address for speaking requests and it’s rare that a nichum aveilim visit is not met with a request for tender words of chizuk and consolation. But Baruch Cohen is not a man who lives in sadness. Whereas tragedy brings pain and profound sadness, he resists thoughts that may lead to depression and attains nechamah from the fact that, though his daughter has died, her neshamah is everlasting.

“I feel a close connection to Hindy’s neshamah. I have a fidelity and awareness to her neshamah that I always try to honor. It’s a mindset and it brings me tremendous consolation. I don’t carry myself as defeated or destroyed, it’s not in my DNA.”

He reasoned that Hashem wanted him to have this experience for a specific purpose. “So where does this pain lead me?” he asked himself. “What middos are surfacing? How can I inspire others?”

Baruch Cohen’s focus is on grieving rather than healing, because it’s a critical stage that is typically overlooked but can’t be bypassed. This realization has brought his learning to a rare and unusual level that has provided insight not only to those who share his unique “lenses,” but to many others seeking growth in Torah and hashkafah.

“My learning now is my own charted path,” he says. “I’m learning on a high level b’iyun, sourcing 20 to 30 mefarshim on a topic. But I’ve redefined myself and my approach to learning. I’m not learning the regular topics; I’m finding and sharing gems of insights normally not recognized.

“Yes, my focus is on grief,” he admits, “but that’s not because I’m mired in sadness. It’s because that grief became my channel to a learning regimen that motivates and inspires me. We all have difficulties in our lives, and our job is to remember that the ‘obstacle is the way.’ Those seeming obstacles often point us in the direction we need to grow closer to Hashem.”

(Originally featured in ‘One Day Closer’, Special Supplement, Chanuka/Siyum HaShas 5780)